Our team at Sitter Insurance is committed to delivering exceptional service with a blend of expertise and warmth, ensuring that every interaction is both informative and reassuring. We offer a full range of solutions designed to meet life's evolving moments, tailoring our approach to each of your unique needs. By providing products that help minimize everyday risks and pave the way for future aspirations, we aim to be more than just a provider - we strive to be a trusted partner in every stage of life's journey.
Liz Parry
Manager
Jessica McIntosh
Agent
Dan Labrozzi
Agent
Tina Varos
Agent
Trisha Shallenbarger
Agent
Shahed Latzo
Agent
Tony Cusati
President
PULL UP A SEAT!
Life's easier with
expert insurance pros
in your corner.
INSURANCE INSIGHT, NO BORING BITS
AGENCY INTRO VIDEO
We'll make sure you have the right coverage, the right discounts, and can take comfort in knowing the things that matter most to you are protected. We also believe in giving back.
5 REASONS VIDEO.
We see 5 main reasons why people suffer financial devastation when mayhem strikes. We made this video to make sure this doesn't happen to you.
Need someone nearby who knows their stuff? Start here. These local businesses help keep life moving, projects rolling, and communities connected. Think of this as your preferred A-list of services that are the talk of the town! Plus, it's an important way to help our community stay strong and kicking!
For better coverage,
SIT down with us!
For better coverage,
SIT down with us!
The employees at my insurance company have always been easy to work with, professional, helpful and pleasant. Thanks for all you do!
Stacey Steen
July 17, 2026
Always ready with sound advice.
Marietta Stalsky
July 17, 2026
I’m so happy with my insurance and my agent They have been with me through all my changes and growth They have been helpful and supportive throughout the years 💕
Deborah Chludzinski
July 17, 2026
I was referred to Sitter Insurance by a family member to try to save money on my car and homeowner's insurance. Liz Parry was fantastic in determining my needs for coverages and limits at a price that was literally hundreds less than I was paying at AAA. She is knowledgeable and very pleasant to deal with. I highly recommend Sitter Insurance!,,
Shelley Torrey
July 16, 2026
I've been with Sitter Insurance for 35 years, great agency with great people.
Randall Hodges
July 16, 2026
Tony is very knowledgeable and friendly. Feels like we’ve made a friend.
Laurie
July 16, 2026
Always helpful with questions and or paying our auto insurance by phone.
Debbie Anderson
July 15, 2026
Great service!!!
John Crowley
July 15, 2026
Great customer service
Robert Valencic
July 15, 2026
The office staff is eager to help. I have insured my vehicles, home and camper through the Agency for many years. The rates that are able to provide through their carriers are matched by the service they provide.
Amber Barber
July 15, 2026
Great availability, communication, and ease of changing agents!!
Carolyn Kuhl
July 15, 2026
Excellent service and solid knowledge of the products and the customer's needs. Highly recommend.
Timothy McNair
July 15, 2026
Always so polite and easy to deal with
Mrs. Brown
July 15, 2026
Great service.
Robert Schulz
July 15, 2026
A few years ago, Sitter Insurance provided substantive, timely and reasonably priced commercial insurance coverage when our former provider could not. My partners and I were very pleased! And today? Sitter Insurance continues to be my provider of choice for all personal insurance needs. Any time my husband and I needed support we could get a response same day. Thank you!
Patricia Nagelkirk
July 15, 2026
I love our agent Anna! See is amazing.
R Scott Domowicz
July 15, 2026
Sitter Insurance is a great team of Insurance agents that know the industry and get you properly insured. They are super competitive and very responsive to all inquiries. I have nothing but the best words to describe these folks. Thank you Tony, Joe , and Liz for your outstanding service! Anyone shopping for insurance make sure to check them out.
Aleksandr Osmak
July 15, 2026
Our insurance company for the 36 years we have been in our home. They have treated us very well.
Frank Singer
July 15, 2026
Liz was so helpful in talking through my options prior to renewals and figured out the best options that protect us in the event of a bad day, but also are realistic for us to manage from a price perspective. Quick responses and very easy to work with!
Courtney Stoll
July 15, 2026
We have used Sitter Insurance for our home, auto, and small business for years. When we retired and moved to NC, we kept Sitter for both Home and Auto. Our rates are great, and the service we get when we have questions about invoices or coverage changes is answered by a real person we know.
Fred Ayers
July 15, 2026
I can call with what seems like the biggest problem ever and Liz will break down everything so I can truly understand! Couldn’t ask for a better agent and insurance company!
JoAnna Baldini
July 15, 2026
Good insurance provider
Seth dinicola
July 15, 2026
thank you so much for always putting Your customers first!
Ryelee Blake
July 15, 2026
Everyone at Sitter Insurance is great and so very helpful!! Liz goes out of her way to always make sure we have the best coverage for our needs!!! Would and have highly recommended them to friends and family!! They will always make sure you have the best coverage!!
Melanie Chow
July 15, 2026
Very polite and professional with handling my policy and questions! Would not go anywhere else for insurance needs.
John Peterson
July 15, 2026
We will look into some life insurance policies for my good friends. We will be in contact JOHN FITZGERALD D. ♤
John
December 15, 2025
Tony, Liz and the entire team at Sitter Ins go above and beyond to make sure you have the best coverage for the best price. They are super knowledgeable, caring, patient, and very efficient! Thank you, everyone for all of your amazing guidance!
Heena Patel
December 7, 2025
Very helpful and knowledgeable on my auto and home insurance needs
Al kemnec
August 7, 2025
Staff is very helpful and friendly. They went out of there way to help me. And there the best rates and coverage I found. Thank you Dennis Forinash
Dennis Forinash
August 5, 2025
My agent, Liz Parry at Sitter Insurance has been extremely helpful in lowering my premiums (Erie Insurance auto and renters). She went over my policy and my rates are very affordable now. I’ve been with them for many years and would highly recommend them for your insurance needs!! Thank you again, Liz!
Dave moskot
July 28, 2025
We have been with Sitter Insurance for many years. They are always available to answer any question we have about our coverage and inform us when something new is available which could be useful to us. I highly recommend them.
Kathy Williams
July 24, 2025
We have been with Sitter Insurance for over 20 years and they have always been incredibly helpful and knowledgeable.
Susan Herberg
July 14, 2025
Liz Parry always does her best to get me a rate that suits my needs as well as my bank balance. After some universal price hikes a couple years back i tried shopping around a bit and I couldn't find anyone that could beat the rates from this place. Luckily have never needed to make use of my policy so cant speak in that regard but I'm assuming they would be just as helpful and responsive in the event i needed to.
Jacks Phone
July 10, 2025
Great helpful staff and caring.
Mike Anderson
July 6, 2025
Everyone at the agency has been great to work with. Anna follows up in any questions I have.
Julianne Duda
July 3, 2025
Insurance provided by someone who knows who you are. The way it should be.
Matt Roach
July 1, 2025
I needed a quote on a homeowners policy quickly for a closing on a property. Anna was both helpful and understanding. 30+ years with Rutkowski insurance and the team always impressed. Thank you!
CAS Laptop
June 27, 2025
Great agent for a great insurance company. Very helpful and knowledgeable.
David A
July 15, 2024
Very good company to get insurance for auto, home, and boat!
Paul Olszewski
February 28, 2024
(Translated by Google) Cool guys (Original) Классные ребята
Fiodar Palkhouski
August 15, 2019
Even though I only had a car insured by Erie Insurance for 7 months, I still had an amazing experience with Mike Figurski. I have 0 knowledge of cars and insurance and such and Mike really made the entire process of signing up for auto insurance so easy. Always professional and courteous, Mike replied to all my questions and concerns in a timely and efficient manner. Thanks again Mike!
NaruAvaFan999
June 21, 2019